Comparing Dr Who episodes by decade

1 Comment

A little while ago, io9 rated every Dr. Who episode from best to worst.

I immediately noticed that a bunch of their favorites were from the reboot, despite the fact that there’s a lot more content in the older series. So I decided to pull the data into R to see if I was imagining things. I know this isn’t fundraising-related, but it IS R related, and it was a fun project to work on over lunch.

Here’s a plot of all the episodes with year on the x-axis and rank on the y-axis. Remember that higher rank is worse.

dr-who-episode-rankings

It definitely LOOKS like the new stuff is better, but I’ll bet we can know more.

Here’s what I found, grouping all the episodes by rounding the year to the nearest decade (ie. 1953 becomes 1950; 1958 becomes 1960):

Let’s Look at Averages

In terms of mean rank, the reboot was WAY better than everything (and the 1990s stuff had an overall average rank that was much worse):

You can see there that, on average, the 2000 decades were the best and the 1990s were the worst.

T-test to really see

But this is just averages–seems like we can do better. I mean, there could be an outlier sitting out there yanking those averages down (or up, as it were).

With that in mind, I ran a t.test to compare each year to another:

Here I’m asking whether the p-values are less than .05. Or to put it another way, is there less than a 5% chance that the difference we’re seeing in the averages for each decade occurred by chance? TRUE values are where there is a smaller than 5% chance that the difference is statistically signficant.

Old Stuff Was A Crapshoot

The other thing you can see is that the old stuff was all over the map. You can see this from the plot above, but there’s not a statistically significant difference in ranks between the 60s, 70s, 80s and 90s. I found that surprising–everybody knows that stuff at the very end of the first series was awful, right? Not io9, apparently.

In any case, if you’re introducing your friends to Dr. Who, start with the reboot–that old stuff is like a box of chocolates….

Categories: assessment Tags: Tags:

One Reply to “Comparing Dr Who episodes by decade”

  1. The fact that back in the 50s 60s 70s 80s not many people had a TV set and the internet was not even invented is not taking into consideration. Information and how easy one can get access to it is a critical factor in what you are trying to prove. For example I find Tom Baker the best Dr who because as a child I didn’t have a vhs player to play the old series and this is the comparison for me, nowadays almost anyone can google something and get an idea of what was is will be.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *